h1

Dumbing Down the News

January 6, 2009

So I see this article today, and I get to the third paragraph…

weight

Huh?  What??  Mass is “like weight”???  A 5th grader could probably tell you mass is not “like weight.”  A two second Google search for the definition of mass reveals that mass “the property of a body that causes it to have weight in a gravitational field.”  Mass is the amount of matter that a body contains.  Apply that matter to gravity, and you have weight, which varies by the strength of the gravitational field.  In other words, you might weigh 100 pounds on Earth, but you’d only weight 38 pounds on Mars, with has 38% the gravity of Earth.   But your mass wouldn’t change.  Mass is a description of the object.  Weight is a description of the force of gravity on the object.

Wikipedia says regarding mass that “the distinction between mass and weight becomes important for measurements with a precision better than a few percent (due to slight differences in the strength of the Earth’s gravitational field at different places), and for places far from the surface of the Earth, such as in space or on other planets. (emphasis added).  Too funny, given the article above.

Are we too stupid in this country to know the difference?  Do we really have to have it explained to us as “like weight?”  Let’s look at it another way.  Newton’s Second Law, dealing with inertial mass, states in equation form that  F = ma (force equals mass times acceleration).  So if a pro baseball player threw a baseball at you, the force of it hitting you is equal to the mass of the ball times the acceleration of it coming at you.  Quite different than if I lobbed one at you.  I bet if the author was hit by the lobbed ball, and then by the 100 mile per hour fastball, he wouldn’t think that they were like each other at all, even though the mass of the ball is the same.  Hmm…. let’s try it and find out!

Share: add to del.icio.us|add to furl|Digg it|add to ma.gnolia|Stumble It!|add to simpy|seed the vine|||TailRank|post to facebook

Advertisements

2 comments

  1. Sorry, misposted before. Hadn’t finished or reviewed.

    Mass is a hard concept for the layman to wrap their brains around. I found the statement of “which is like weight” to be appropriate, albeit wrong, for an audience like this. Second best would be if they didn’t mention it at all. A full on explanation would just confuse things.
    Also, you’re baseball example is wrong. The acceleration of a ball going 100mph is zero. Acceleration is a measure of the change of velocity over time so a ball going a consistent speed has zero acceleration. You want to be looking at Energy transferred not Force to get the ball moving. E=1/2mV^2. This will better represent the difference between lobbing a ball and really chucking it.
    Nice post. You’ve got me coming back.


  2. Interesting response. I do believe stand corrected. *bows*

    I do think mass vs. weight might be difficult for some people to grasp. But my contention with the author of the piece is that if the correct explanation is too lengthy, don’t use a faulty one and call it a day. That’s like saying Germans killed Jews in World War II rather than saying Nazi’s killed Jews, because you think your readers might not know what a Nazi is. In general, don’t talk down to your readers and assume they don’t know what you’re talking about.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: